| 7 mins read
SUMMARY
- UK territorial politics is shifting away from a Celtic-only model toward English regionalism, driven by Northern resentment of the South, Andy Burnham’s Head North, and the July 2026 Cabinet Statement, Rewiring the State.
- Westminster must shift from top-down micromanagement to a more strategic role, treating devolution as a positive rather than a loss of power.
- Expanding devolution across England requires funding for poorer areas and rebuilding local administrative capacity.
- There may be hurdles ahead, including internal Northern rivalries, local government disputes and a potential Southern backlash.
A new territorial politics?
The territorial integrity of the United Kingdom is remarkable given its peculiar composition. A polity consisting of four nations, multiple languages and religions, three legal systems, and deep territorial inequalities seems inauspicious. But its territorial integrity has endured since 1922 because the UK state devolved power to Celtic nations that had become increasingly intolerant of what was called ‘distant government’, a trend that eventually left England exposed as the most centralised nation in Europe. Such asymmetrical devolution was attributed to the absence of English regionalism, described by Christopher Harvie as ‘the dog that never barked’.
This traditional narrative of devolution – casting the Celtic nations as leaders and England as the laggard – risks becoming redundant, as asymmetrical devolution has acquired a new meaning in the wake of Andy Burnham’s ‘devolution revolution’. The new strategy is sketched in the Statement from the Cabinet in July 2026, Rewiring the State.
Territorial politics within England, especially the English North, are now shaping devolution across the UK. Analysis by Munis et al suggests that Northern grievance is now shaping English politics, with resentment of the South emerging as the most politically consequential form of territorial politics in England today. Early days, but the dog has finally barked.
What this means for the Celtic nations is unclear. The three Devolved Administrations have taken fright and called for similar powers and resources to be extended to their regions.
Rewiring the State: three territorial challenges
As a vision for devolution in England, the Cabinet Statement has the potential to be among the most significant proposals ever issued by a UK government. But this new vision faces three territorial challenges.
1. Reinventing the central state
In territorial terms, the UK is an international outlier in two important but inter-related respects: it has pronounced, and stubborn regional inequalities, and its governance system is among the most centralised, top-down, and space-blind in the industrialised world. Reforming the central state is often framed in zero-sum terms: the gains of cities and regions must spell losses for the centre. But devolving power can be a positive-sum game: it can relieve the micromanagement burden of central government, allowing it to become a more agile and strategic level of government.
2. Devolved polities
The process of subnational devolution has been highly asymmetrical in England in two respects: between devolved areas and non-devolved areas on the one hand and within the devolved areas on the other. Apart from creating a nationwide system of devolution in England, the key challenges facing the devolved polities are likely to be (a) how to calibrate subsidiarity and solidarity with respect to the poorest places, where fiscal devolution generates lower revenue streams than in more prosperous places and (b) how to devolve power when subnational government has been denuded of so much capacity and capability?
Equalisation measures will need to be introduced to address the spatially uneven impacts of fiscal devolution, without neutering the growth incentives of fiscal devolution for more dynamic places. The capacity and capability challenge is a chicken-and-egg problem: where powers cannot be devolved unless authorities have the absorptive capacity, they cannot develop the latter without exercising the former.
3. Celtic nations
The Celtic nations have loomed largest in the devolution debate until recently because they were the original beneficiaries of the national model of devolution. But city regionalism has spawned a new subnational model of devolution, triggering tensions between the Celtic nations and the UK government. Territorial tensions are compounded by the fact that, for the first time in history, the Celtic nations are now led by First Ministers that are formally committed to leaving the UK.
These territorial tensions peaked under the ‘muscular unionism’ of Conservative governments, which asserted the primacy of the unitary UK state, as they sought to bypass the Devolved Administrations and deal directly with local governments in the design and delivery of the Shared Prosperity Fund.
Perhaps the main territorial challenge for the UK government is how to show respect for the devolved competences of the three Celtic nations, whilst unequivocally demonstrating that central government has a legitimate mandate to govern the whole UK.
Andy Burnham and the Politics of Place
In Head North, Burnham treats ‘the North’ as a political subject, as a place with a distinctive historical experience and a strong tradition of collective action. Head North provides the clearest evidence of the regional dog barking in England.
But the North contains its own rivalries and suspicions. Tensions between mayors and local councils are apparent. Local government reform is contentious. A Southern backlash against preferential treatment of the North is in the making. Serious questions remain about the model of democratic accountability that accompanies city-regionalism and the absence of a civic and democratic culture to underpin local and regional governance.
It is no exaggeration to describe this moment as a potential historical turning point in which the state and territorial politics may be recast in potentially profound ways. But success is hardly a foregone conclusion. Six centuries ago, Machiavelli warned Lorenzo de’ Medici:
It should be borne in mind that there is nothing more difficult to handle, more doubtful of success, and more dangerous to carry through than initiating changes in a state's constitution.
But Machiavelli knew that in addition to strategy, the Prince needs Fortune to achieve his ends.
This digested read of a journal article was created by the authors.
Need help using Wiley? Click here for help using Wiley