Theme: Parties & Elections | Content Type: Journal article

Free to read

Fighting across the Independence Divide: The SNP, Scottish Labour and the Persistence of Constitutional Divisions in the 2024 and 2026 Elections

Marta Miori

shutterstock_2763060963

Shutterstock

| 1 min read

After a decade in which Scotland's independence divide sustained the Scottish National Party's electoral advantage over Labour, the 2024 Westminster and 2026 Holyrood elections reversed the two parties’ fortunes in quick succession. Using British Election Study Internet Panel (BESIP) data, I examine how these reversals occurred without substantial constitutional realignment. First, Labour's 2024 gains came mainly from broadening its support among pro-union voters from across the ideological spectrum, while it made only limited inroads among pro-independence voters. Second, the SNP regained the lead in 2026 with little direct switching from Labour: it retained a stable core of support and won back some of its former pro-independence voters, while Labour's unusually broad 2024 coalition dispersed to other parties or abstained. These patterns show how party fortunes can flip in Scotland even while the independence divide continues to structure competition within the Scottish left, especially when turnout and fragmentation within the ‘Yes’ and ‘No’ blocs shift from one election to the next.

Read the full article on Wiley

Need help using Wiley? Click here for help using Wiley

  • Marta Miori

    Marta Miori is a doctoral student in the Department of Politics at the University of Manchester.

    Articles by Marta Miori