Theme: Government & Parliament | Content Type: Digested Read

Why Is the British Right Calling for ‘Constitutional Restoration’?

James Dennison

shutterstock_1931796512

Shutterstock

| 7 mins read

SUMMARY

  • There is an emerging political narrative of ‘constitutional restoration’ on the British right.
  • It connects long-standing conservative concerns with recent controversies on issues such as Brexit, the pandemic, and immigration.
  • Britain's various challenges are presented as the product of constitutional transformation, centred on the expansion of rights-based legal constitutionalism, judicial authority, agencies and statutory constraints on Parliament.
  • These supposedly disrupt Britain's political constitutional tradition and equilibrium, democratic responsiveness and national identity.

What do Britain’s difficulties with immigration, policing, economic stagnation and government effectiveness have in common? Increasingly, some politicians, historians and constitutional lawyers on the British right offer an ambitious answer: the constitution.

Their argument is that Britain has progressively abandoned its historic political constitution, in which Parliament, the Crown and the common law maintained a complex balance of authority, in favour of a new order dominated by legal rights, judicial supervision, technocratic agencies and statutory constraints on democratic decision-making.

The solution, they argue, is not simply better policies or politicians, but constitutional restoration. This emerging narrative deserves attention, not least because it connects several of the most contentious issues in British politics to a single explanation of national decline and renewal.

How has Britain’s constitution changed?

Unlike most democracies, Britain has no single codified constitutional document. Its constitution has historically depended upon evolving relationships between institutions, sustained by conventions, restraint and political judgement. Yet these relationships have changed substantially.

The Parliament Acts of 1911 and 1949 weakened the House of Lords, while the growth of disciplined political parties increasingly concentrated authority within the executive. The subsequent expansion of judicial review, including its extension to prerogative powers following the 1984 GCHQ case, brought ministers under greater judicial supervision. Later reforms, notably the Human Rights Act 1998, devolution and the creation of the Supreme Court, further altered the constitutional settlement. Statutory duties concerning equality and climate change have also introduced constraints on government action.

The constitutional significance of these developments is contested. Scholars such as Martin Loughlin, Nick Barber and John Allison have examined, from different perspectives, the changing relationship between parliamentary sovereignty, the common law, individual rights and judicial authority. These are serious constitutional debates, not inventions of contemporary politicians. But recognising the extent of constitutional change is different from accepting that it explains Britain’s current difficulties.

From constitutional criticism to constitutional restoration

Conservative constitutional objections long predate Brexit. Yet Brexit transformed their political significance. In 2019, following the Supreme Court’s prorogation judgment, Martin Howe KC called for a Restoration of the Constitution Bill reversing much of the post-1997 constitutional settlement.

Thereafter, the pandemic, controversies surrounding asylum and immigration, disputes over policing, and continued economic stagnation gave new political relevance to previously specialised constitutional questions. Historian David Starkey has been particularly clear in connecting these developments into a broader historical narrative. His argument is not simply that individual reforms were mistaken, but that Britain has abandoned constitutional arrangements integral to its national identity and democratic government.

Similar themes increasingly appear across the contemporary right, including in statements by Kemi Badenoch, Danny Kruger and Rupert Lowe. What is emerging is more than a collection of constitutional reform proposals. It is a political narrative: a selective, coherent account that connects apparently unrelated problems to a common cause and proposes a corresponding remedy.

Why might this narrative resonate?

Political narratives help people make sense of complicated events. Their appeal depends partly on whether they offer plausible explanations for concerns that audiences already hold. That makes restorationism potentially consequential. YouGov data show declining confidence in the police and judiciary, particularly among Leave voters. Gallup has similarly reported especially low judicial confidence among Reform supporters.

poqu70156-fig-0001-m

Figure: Net confidence in the police and judiciary, 2020–2026, distinguishing Leave and Remain voters, Gallup.

Restorationism offers a common explanation for these grievances. Difficulties with asylum policy become evidence of excessive judicial authority; economic stagnation reflects constraints on political discretion; controversies over policing suggest that universal equality before the law has been displaced by competing statutory rights and obligations.

The narrative’s political appeal may therefore depend less on proving every causal claim than on its capacity to organise existing dissatisfaction. This is also why constitutional restorationism matters beyond Britain. It illustrates how political actors can transform established intellectual arguments into broader narratives of political decline and renewal.

What does restorationism get right—and wrong?

Several of restorationism’s underlying criticisms deserve consideration. Political institutions can accumulate authority beyond their original purposes. Courts and technocratic agencies cannot be entirely value-neutral, and specialised institutions may struggle to balance competing public goods. Universalist principles can also sit uneasily within a constitution historically dependent upon political accommodation and restraint.

But these observations do not establish the narrative’s much more ambitious causal claims. Would Britain have experienced significantly different immigration outcomes, pandemic governance, policing or economic performance without the constitutional reforms of recent decades? The answers are likely to vary considerably.

There is also a deeper problem with restoration itself. Britain’s constitution has no single founding moment. It is continuously developed through changing institutional relationships and political practices. Restorationists must therefore select which historical arrangements they wish to recover and which subsequent developments they wish to retain. Indeed, the relative absence of demands to reverse devolution is striking. Restoring Britain’s constitution would itself constitute constitutional change.

Redeeming rather than restoring the constitution

Britain’s constitutional challenges cannot necessarily be resolved by removing legal constraints upon Parliament. A stronger political constitution also requires stronger political institutions.

One alternative is to rebuild effective bicameralism, representing the United Kingdom both as a single political community through proportional, partisan representation in the Commons and territorially through a reformed, elected House of Lords. Political parties and their funding also deserve more formal constitutional recognition, while Parliament requires greater resources and independent expertise to scrutinise government effectively. Such reforms would seek to strengthen democratic institutions while preserving rights and liberties, rather than simply reversing previous constitutional developments.

The strength of Britain’s constitution has historically lain not in the supremacy of one institution or principle, but in the accommodation between multiple sources of authority. The challenge is therefore not necessarily to restore an earlier constitution, but to redeem a changing one.

Digested read of a longer journal article created by the author.

Read the full article on Wiley

Need help using Wiley? Click here for help using Wiley

  • James Dennison

    James Dennison

    James Dennison is a part-time Professor at the Migration Policy Centre of the European University Institute and a Researcher at the Department of Sociology of the University of Stockholm.

    Articles by James Dennison